Mellon Collie & The Infinite Sadness Appreciation Thread

[The Amerikkkan Idol]

Double CD

28 Songs

20 of them killer

Yes, I know you don't like Billy Corgan(who could blame you), but Jimmy Chamberlain is the best drummer on planet earth(yeah, I said it), and Corgan is a brilliant songwriter and guitar player. This is a classic and deserves to sit at the top of anybody's "best albums" list.

I know you wanna hate, but go listen to it again, and hear how good it sounds 10 years later.

[watthafuc]

top 10 of any genre hands down...

the piano intro on the first cd is fukkin ill

[Borg166]

<--- huge Pumpkins fan

I like pretty much everything they've released, even Machina.

[AnotherGirl]

<--- huge Pumpkins fan
I like pretty much everything they've released, even Machina.

same but if we're talking album appreciation...Siamese Dream > Melloncollie. Gish is prolly my second favorite.

[Dub Ste]

Fantastic album, certainly one of my favourite albums ever.

agree with the jimmy chamberlain comments, his drumming, particularly on this album, is unbelievable

[Borg166]

same but if we're talking album appreciation...Siamese Dream > Melloncollie.

I agree with that. Siamese Dream is their best album, but I usually find myself listening to Adore the most for some reason.

[The Amerikkkan Idol]

same but if we're talking album appreciation...Siamese Dream > Melloncollie. Gish is prolly my second favorite.


Rocket & Mayonaise>>>>>>everything on the radio today put together.